Summary
Negative pathogen test results obtained before shipment do not always prevent the later detection of Salmonella or pathogenic E. coli in leafy greens once products reach the market or are consumed. When this happens, it can lead to recalls with high economic costs and loss of confidence in testing programs. These situations suggest that pathogens may sometimes be present but temporarily difficult to detect due to how products are handled, stored, or tested before shipping. This project aims to improve the reliability of pre-shipping pathogen testing by identifying which representative current pre-harvest and post-harvest management practices most strongly affect whether pathogens are detected. Current industrial practices along the supply chain will be combined with adapted procedures at pre-shipping and evaluated under controlled laboratory and pilot-scale conditions. This will enable understanding how factors such as pre-harvest wetting, sampling approaches, holding time and temperature, and detection methods influence pathogen detection at early post-harvest stages. These results will be combined with industry variability to build models that estimate how likely pathogens are to be detected under different conditions. Lastly, the project will provide practical, evidence-based guidance to help growers, processors, and laboratories improve pre-shipping testing decisions and reduce the risk of false-negative results.
Technical Abstract
Negative pre-shipping test results under mandatory pathogen surveillance in the leafy greens industry do not always prevent post-distribution or post-consumption detection of Salmonella and pathogenic Escherichia coli, resulting in recalls with significant economic impact. These events call into question the reliability of negative test results, which may be influenced by pathogen physiological status, extended lag phases during resuscitation, and/or in-distribution population increases following pre-shipping operational and procedural steps. This project aims to identify representative current preharvest and postharvest management practices for leafy greens industry to identify and prioritize those factors most effectively improving pathogen detection reliability and decision-making. Using CPS-funded datasets complemented with already available research studies, industrial advice and historical data from food safety data sharing platforms (e.g., GreenLink, WGA), a harmonized dataset describing operational and procedural steps will be first constructed to characterize critical industrial practices potentially determinative of pathogen detectability (Objective 1). Rather than assuming expanded industry data availability, the project is intentionally designed to leverage existing data to focus on learning which categories of operational metadata are most informative for detection reliability and decision-making. These representative current preharvest and postharvest management practices identified in Objective 1 will represent the standard conditions. Objective 2 will then examine, under controlled laboratory and pilot-scale conditions, determinative pre-shipping operational and procedural steps that allow pathogen detection in early post-harvest stages (pre-shipping). The individual current and adapted procedures, to which leafy greens (e.g. baby spinach) will be subjected, include: pre-harvest wetting (e.g., naturally occurring moisture such as heavy dew), sampling plan, holding temperature and time, and analytical workflows (e.g., enrichment type and duration, post-enrichment concentration, detection methods). Each of these procedures will be evaluated individually while all other conditions are maintained constant across the three representative operational stages (pre-shipping, distribution and POP/POS or in-home), allowing comparisons to baseline conditions and enabling direct attribution of observed differences in detection outcomes to specific operational or methodological variables. Both industrial operational variability and experimental data will then be used to develop predictive models to quantify the effects of operational and analytical factors on pathogen detection, including estimation of odds ratios and multivariable associations (Objective 3). The resulting framework will enable prioritization of pre-shipping conditions and procedural steps that most strongly influence pathogen detectability, ultimately informing practical, scenario-based guidance for improved decision-making (Objective 4). The main outcomes of the project are:
- Delivery of a harmonized dataset summarizing parameter ranges and associated detection and non-detection outcomes.
- Measurable increase in detection probability at pre-shipping under adapted procedures compared to baseline conditions.
- Identification and ranking of key operational and procedural leverage points contributing most strongly to false-negative risk.
- Development of an evidence-based guidance document outlining prioritized pre-shipping operational and procedural recommendations.
Research Objectives
Objective 1 – Identification and characterization of current industrial practices potentially determinative of pathogen detectability
To identify and prioritize representative current preharvest and postharvest management practices across the leafy greens industry by synthesizing CPS-funded research, published literature, and industry inputs (e.g., GreenLink, WGA). This synthesis will generate harmonized datasets linking operational practices and analytical procedures with historical pre-shipping detection and non-detection outcomes. Where available, links between pre-shipping conditions and downstream recalls or outbreaks will be also explored to better inform the selection of realistic scenarios for controlled evaluation in Objective 2.
Objective 2 – Experimental evaluation of pre-shipping operations (including sample-handling practices and analytical procedures) to enhance detection
To experimentally evaluate, under controlled laboratory and pilot-scale conditions, the effects of representative current preharvest and postharvest management practices identified in Objective 1, including early pre-shipping, distribution, and POP/POS or in-home handling, as well as alternative sampling and analytical procedures, on pathogen physiological state and detectability.
Objective 3 – Statistical analysis and development of predictive models for pathogen detection probability
To develop predictive models (statistical, probabilistic and simulation-based) that quantify the effects of operational and analytical factors on pathogen detection on leafy greens, combining industrial operational variability (Objective 1) and experimental data (Objective 2), including estimation of odds ratios and multivariable associations. The resulting framework will enable prioritization of representative current preharvest and postharvest management practices that most strongly influence pathogen recovery potential, and analytical detectability.
Objective 4 – Translation of findings into prioritized, evidence-based industry guidance
To translate experimental (Objective 2) and modeling outcomes (Objective 3) into practical, ready-to-use guidance for pre-shipping operations and pathogen testing for improving pathogen detectability and confidence in surveillance outcomes. This objective will focus on identifying the minimum and most critical information needed for reliable decision-making and translating these insights into targeted, operationally feasible recommendations on preharvest and postharvest management practices and analytical procedures that enhance detection robustness.
Findings & Recommendations
This project is ongoing. A final report will be provided when the project is finished.